Tag Archives: disgorgement

SoxLaw  /  SoxLaw.com Resources  /  disgorgement
09 Mar 2023

Understanding SEC Fines: Where Do They Go and How Do They Benefit Investors?

Categories Sarbanes–Oxley Act

What Happens to the Fines Collected by the SEC?

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) plays a crucial role in enforcing regulations and penalizing individuals or corporations found guilty of violating SEC rules. When fines are imposed as part of a civil action, the collected money serves various purposes, including compensating investors who have suffered from securities law violations.

Key Takeaways

  • The SEC is America’s regulator for the securities industry and markets.
  • Securities violations can include insider trading, accounting fraud, and securities fraud.
  • Penalties and disgorgements from SEC actions go to the U.S. Treasury, the SEC, and victims’ and whistleblowers’ funds.
  • In 2021, the SEC collected $1.4 billion in penalties and $2.4 billion in disgorgements.

The SEC and Its Role The Securities and Exchange Commission is an independent regulatory agency established by the federal government through the U.S. Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Its creation was prompted by the stock market crash of 1929 and the subsequent Great Depression.

The SEC’s primary objectives include establishing and enforcing regulations for securities markets, issuers, and brokers. It aims to protect investors and ensure transparency in financial markets.

SEC Penalty Enforcement When the SEC imposes penalties, they fall into two categories: civil money penalties and disgorgements. Civil penalties involve fines paid by defendants held liable for damages. In the past, these penalties were directed to the U.S. Department of the Treasury.

Disgorgements, on the other hand, are remedial civil actions that aim to restore funds acquired through illegal or unethical business transactions, along with interest, to the affected parties. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 empowered the SEC to distribute disgorgement funds and civil money penalties to victims of securities law violations through the Fair Funds for Investors provision.

SEC Penalty Examples The SEC has taken notable enforcement actions against individuals and companies for securities law violations. Examples include cases of insider trading and fraudulent accounting. Martha Stewart, Jeffrey Skilling, Raj Rajaratnam, and Steven A. Cohen are among those who faced penalties for their involvement in such offenses.

What Does the SEC Do With Money It Collects From Fines? The SEC utilizes the collected fines based on the nature of the penalty. If investors or others have suffered financial harm, the penalties are used to compensate for the losses and make the affected parties whole. Prior to the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, all SEC penalties were directed to the U.S. Treasury. However, Section 308 of the act, known as the “Fair Funds provision,” allows the SEC to request that certain penalties be added to disgorgement funds established in enforcement actions to benefit shareholders, investors, whistleblowers, or other victims of securities law violations.

Securities Law Violations and Penalties Securities law violations encompass activities related to insider trading, accounting irregularities, and securities fraud. The severity of penalties depends on the tiered system used by the SEC, considering the nature and intent of the violation. These penalties may range from fines up to $5,000 for individuals and up to $500,000 for corporations, alongside potential prison terms and the requirement to return ill-gotten gains through disgorgement.

Where Do Bank Fines Go? While the SEC primarily regulates the securities industry, banks are overseen by other entities such as the Federal Reserve and state-level banking regulators. When federal fines are imposed on banks, they are allocated to the U.S. Treasury, the Federal Reserve, the Department of Justice (including victims’ funds), and state bank regulatory authorities.

For more information and additional resources, refer to the following:

Websites and Online Resources:

  1. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) – Official Website
  2. Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 – SEC Guide

Books:

  1. “The SEC and Regulation of Exchange-Traded Funds” by Tamar Frankel
  2. “The Law of Governance, Risk Management, and Compliance” by Geoffrey P. Miller

Academic Journals and Research Papers:

  1. “The Role and Impact of the SEC in Financial Reporting Quality: A Review” – Journal of Accounting and Economics
  2. “The Effects of SEC Enforcement and Earnings Quality on Firm Value” – The Accounting Review

Reports and Studies:

  1. “SEC Enforcement Activity Annual Reports” – U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
  2. “Disgorgement: Assessing the SEC’s Penalties in Financial Fraud Cases” – U.S. Government Accountability Office

Professional Organizations and Associations:

  1. American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) – Official Website
  2. Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) – Official Website
01 Oct 2022

LAWS & REGULATIONS: SEC Fair Funds for Investors

Categories Sarbanes–Oxley Act

Definition The Fair Funds for Investors provision was introduced in 2002 under Section 308(a) of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX). It aims to benefit investors who have suffered financial losses due to illegal or unethical activities by individuals or companies violating securities regulations. This provision enables the return of wrongful profits, penalties, and fines to defrauded investors.

Key Takeaways

  • The Fair Funds for Investors provision was introduced in 2002 under Section 308(a) of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX).
  • It returns wrongful profits, penalties, and fines to defrauded investors.
  • Previously, money recovered by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) from regulatory violators was disbursed to the U.S. Treasury, with no direct distribution to victimized investors.

Understanding Fair Funds for Investors Before the Fair Funds Provision, money recovered by the SEC through civil penalties against regulatory violators went to the U.S. Treasury, bypassing distribution to victimized investors. The provision changed this by allowing the SEC to combine civil money penalties with disgorgement funds to provide relief to victims of stock swindles.

Here’s how it works:

  1. The provision establishes a fund to hold money recovered from SEC cases.
  2. The fund determines the distribution of funds to defrauded investors.
  3. After disbursing the funds, the specific fund is terminated.

The Fair Funds for Investors provision has provided compensation to investors victimized by various forms of securities fraud and manipulation, including collusion between funds and brokers, interest-rate fixing, undisclosed fees, false advertising, late trading, pump-and-dump schemes, and mutual fund market timing.

In many cases, victims are unable to pursue private litigation due to inaccessibility or impracticality. The Fair Funds provision becomes their only means of accessing compensation. Research indicates that victims typically receive at least 80% of their losses through Fair Funds distributions when private litigation is not feasible.

Research on the Effectiveness of the Fair Funds for Investors Provision A study conducted by Urska Velikonja of Emory University and published in the Stanford Law Review in 2014 examined the effectiveness of the Fair Funds for Investors provision. The findings revealed the following:

  • Between 2002 and 2013, the provision allowed the SEC to distribute $14.46 billion to investors defrauded by fraud.
  • The average fair fund disbursement is comparable to the average class action settlement disbursement related to securities class action suits.
  • Fair funds compensate investors for various types of misconduct more effectively than private securities litigation, which primarily focuses on accounting fraud.
  • Defendants are more likely to contribute to Fair Funds for Investors distributions compared to paying damages related to private litigation.

Overall, the Fair Funds for Investors provision has proven to be successful in compensating defrauded investors, exceeding the expectations of opponents. It serves as a crucial avenue for victims to seek redress and recover a significant portion of their losses.

Additional Resources

For readers seeking further information on the Fair Funds for Investors provision and related topics, the following resources offer authoritative information and valuable insights:

Websites and Online Resources:

  1. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) – Fair Funds: The official website of the SEC provides comprehensive information on Fair Funds, including relevant laws, regulations, and case studies. Visit the SEC Fair Funds webpage for more details.
  2. Investopedia – Fair Funds: Investopedia offers an informative article explaining the concept of Fair Funds and its significance for defrauded investors. Access the article here to enhance your understanding.

Books:

  1. “Fair Funds and Fairness in Securities Settlements” by Mark C. Mangan: This book explores the legal and practical aspects of Fair Funds provisions, providing an in-depth analysis of their implementation and impact on investor protection. Find the book on Amazon for further reading.
  2. “Sarbanes-Oxley Act: Planning, Implementation, and Compliance” by Scott Green: This comprehensive guidebook covers various aspects of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, including the Fair Funds provision, offering practical insights and strategies for compliance. Get the book on Amazon to delve deeper into the topic.

Academic Journals and Research Papers:

  1. “Public Compensation for Private Harm. Evidence from the SEC’s Fair Fund Distributions” by Urska Velikonja: This research paper published in the Stanford Law Review examines the effectiveness of the Fair Funds provision and provides valuable insights into the distribution of funds to defrauded investors. Access the paper here for detailed analysis.
  2. “Restitution and Fair Funds: A Case Study of Disgorgement and the Compensation of Injured Investors” by Jennifer Arlen: This academic article, published in The Journal of Legal Studies, analyzes the restitution process and Fair Funds provision, shedding light on their role in compensating defrauded investors. Read the article here for a comprehensive perspective.

Reports and Studies:

  1. Government Accountability Office (GAO) Report: “SEC Practices: Additional Actions Needed to Better Deter, Detect, and Respond to Fraudulent Activity”: This report by the GAO assesses the SEC’s practices and provides recommendations for improving fraud detection and response, including insights on Fair Funds. Access the report here to gain valuable information.
  2. Congressional Research Service (CRS) Report: “Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002: A Summary”: This CRS report provides an overview of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, including a section dedicated to the Fair Funds provision, offering a comprehensive understanding of its legislative background. Read the report here for detailed analysis.

Professional Organizations and Associations:

  1. American Bar Association (ABA) – Securities Litigation Committee: The ABA’s Securities Litigation Committee focuses on issues related to securities litigation, including Fair Funds. Visit their website to access resources, publications, and events relevant to the topic.
  2. Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA): FINRA is a regulatory authority overseeing securities firms and brokers. Their website provides insights into investor protection, including resources related to Fair Funds. Explore their Investor Protection section for valuable information.

These resources will provide a wealth of information and diverse perspectives to further enhance your knowledge of the Fair Funds for Investors provision and its implications.